English   |   Kurdî   |   كوردى   |   عربى
Art    Sport    Technology    Miscellaneous
Follow us on:
facebook twitter google + skype rss-feed youtube
US officials colluded with the Iraqi Government, knowingly surrendering the field to Iran
Kurdish genocide: Never again
Barzani on Christmas: No force, ideology can destroy coexistence in Kurdistan
  •  KRG summons Iranian diplomat over CIA accusation on Iran protests
  •  PUK, KDP push for a united Kurdish list in Iraqi elections
  •  KDP to discuss joint list for Iraqi elections, timing for Kurdistan's with PUK
  •  Opposition parties defend meeting with Abadi separate of KRG
  •  Peshmerga and locals celebrate the New Year on front line facing Iraqi forces
  •  Commission prepared to hold Kurdistan elections in April
  •  Erbil health facing critical supply shortages
  •  Iran protests turn deadly: reports
  •  Kurdistan flag banned, Khamenei photo raised in Kirkuk
  •  Iraqi PM extremely arrogant, hinders dialogue between Erbil, Baghdad: Kurdish MP
Last Updated: 17/01/2018 10:23:37 pm
Ted Galen Carpenter - Did Turkey Misuse U.S. Military Hardware?
Did Turkey Misuse U.S. Military Hardware?
Share
Date: 04/06/2012 : 10:54:15Views: 899
  

A simmering diplomatic incident between Ankara and Washington has developed over the use of surveillance information provided by a U.S. Predator drone. In late December 2011, the drone spotted a caravan of 38 men and pack mules on a mountain ridge in the Kurdish region of Turkey near the border with Iraq. U.S. military personnel operating the drone suspected that the caravan consisted of fighters for the insurgent Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) and relayed the information to Turkey’s military command. A short time later, Turkish aircraft attacked the caravan, killing all but four of the men. The incident sparked several riots in towns throughout Turkey’s Kurdish region.

It also caused growing uneasiness at the Pentagon and in Congress. Pentagon officials were quick to insist the United States bore no real responsibility for the attack. They conceded that the drone supplied information about the caravan, but “the Turks made the call,” a senior U.S. Defense Department official emphasized. “It wasn’t an American decision.”

Critics greeted that explanation with some skepticism. The principal concern was whether those killed had really been PKK guerrillas, as Ankara insisted, or whether the men had been garden-variety gasoline smugglers, as most of the evidence indicated. If they had that status, they clearly did not deserve to be slaughtered by Turkish military aircraft. And that possibility highlighted a related concern—whether Ankara had misused sophisticated U.S. military hardware. Worried members of the American foreign policy community asked how far Washington should entrust allies, even a fellow NATO member like Turkey, with deadly drone technology.

It is not the first time that questions have arisen about how a U.S. security partner has utilized American weaponry or intelligence data. There have been numerous calls over the decades to cut-off aid to Pakistan’s military because of acts of aggression those forces have taken against India and coups they have launched against Pakistan’s own civilian government. In the early 1980s, angry members of Congress, as well as human rights activists, called on the White House to curtail military aid to South Korea when the South Korean army overthrew an embryonic democratic government. Critics inside the United States and throughout the Muslim world have repeatedly demanded (to no avail) that U.S. military aid to Israel be restricted because Tel Aviv has used helicopters and other systems to attack Palestinian demonstrators.

Turkey itself has been the target of complaints about improper use of American aid. The most prominent anti-aid campaign occurred after Turkish forces invaded Cyprus in 1974 and occupied nearly 38 percent of that country’s territory. Congress did cut-off military aid to Ankara, although the executive branch managed to restore most of assistance gradually over the next few years. Ankara’s use of U.S.-supplied attack helicopters against Kurdish targets inside Turkey—and even more so beginning in 2008 when those weapon systems were used against accused PKK sanctuaries in northern Iraq—led to renewed calls for severing aid. As in the case of Pakistan, it appeared that U.S. weaponry was, despite supposed prohibitions, being employed to commit aggressive acts against a neighboring country.

The latest incident involving drone intelligence enabling the Turkish military to attack an apparent caravan of smugglers has intensified all of those concerns. U.S. aid, even indirect aid, to such a deadly attack highlights Washington’s moral entanglement in questionable actions that allies such as Turkey undertake. There is also the considerable risk that angry populations who have been the targets of such attacks will hold the United States responsible for any unjustified casualties.

That danger was highlighted during the successful anti-government demonstrations against Hosni Mubarak’s government in Egypt. Demonstrators were noticeably angry at the sight of U.S.-provided helicopters and armored vehicles being used against unarmed civilians who sought to bring democracy to their country. Such anger can lead to the growth of already worrisome anti-American sentiment in the Middle East and other regions. U.S. leaders need to take into account that potential cost the next time they help arm allied governments that have questionable agendas.

Ted Galen Carpenter, a senior fellow at the Cato Institute, is the author of eight books on international affairs and is a member of the editorial board of Mediterranean Quarterly.

Prof. Dr Vladislav B. Sotirović
The Kurdsand Kurdistan
Dr. Anwar A. Abdullah (Al-Barzanji)
Middle East: Out of Control
Davan Yahya Khalil
What Does President Barzani’s Visit to Turkey Mean?
Michael Gunter
THE SYRIAN KURDS AND THE CONFUSING U.S. SECURITY OUTLOOK GIVEN TURKEY’S ATTACKS AGAINST ISIS & THE PKK
Khaled Salih
Kurdistan’s challenges
Dlsoz Hawrami
UN Genocide Convention: It proves so difficult to recognize so many atrocity crimes as Genocide
Professor Jamal Ameen
Order out of Chaos in Kurdistan
Ted Galen Carpenter
Declining Oil Prices Will Not Lead to Iran’s Surrender on the Nuclear Issue
Yasin Aziz
What is meant to be Peshmerga
Saro Qadir
Middle East Negotiations and Kurdistan’s Lack of Strategy
Doğu Ergil
THE FATE OF THE PEACE PROCESS IS AMBIGOUS IN TURKEY
David Romano
Thanks to the Islamic State
Shawnm Yahya
Democracy and Anti- Democracy
Hemin Hawrami
President Barzani and Kurdistan's Advancement and Success during the Past Eight Years
Dr. Mohammed Sharif
Culture of Hostility to Authority Social Disaster
Chaim Kaufmann
How the Whole Middle East Disappeared
Alon Ben-Meir
Syria: The Battleground between Sunnis and Shittes
Shilan bibany
Tower and Cancer
News
  President Barzani Meets French President Hollande in Paris
  Iraqi Kurdistan region to export oil for first time
  Statement by President Barzani on British parliament’s recognition of Kurdish genocide
  Iraqi Army arrests 4 Turkish Anadolu Journalists
  Hebrew University students from around the world celebrate Newroz
  Dr. Kamal Kirkuki meets with Henry A. Kissinger
Reports‌
  Iraq in a stage of post-federalism
  The Iraqi Government Still Able to Implement Agreements
  The Golden Jubilee… A Liberation Medallion for the Motto “Either Kurdistan or Dissolution” The September Revolution Still Ongoing
  The Effects of Media in the Transitional Stages
  Violating the Iraqi Constitution Imposes Autocracy and the Return of Dictatorship
  Different Problems of Democracy Development in the Developing Countries
Exclusive Interviews
  Hayat Alvi to Gulan Magazine:In terms of Islamic ideologies in Egypt, the similarities and perspectives are similar to Wahhabis / Salafists in Saudi Arabia
  Ian S. Lustick to Gulan: I imagine the end of the Syrian Regime will be more like that of the Ceaucescu regime in Romania than of other, less violent, transitions in Eastern Europe
  Interview with the Professor David Romano
  Interview of Javier Solana for Gulan magazine - Iraqi Kurdistan
  Brendan O'Leary to Gulan Magazine: Only a fool would say the break-up of Iraq will never happen
Columns‌
  Kurdistan – a brief history
  Turkey & Kurdistan: Prospects for Complementary Economy
  Recent Western Scholarship on the Kurds in Iraq: A Retrospective
  Iraq amid Democracy & Instability
  Book Review Essay on Halabja & the Anfal
  Kurdistan: Total Solutions for Sustainability
  The Opening of a U.S. Consulate in Hawler
Miscellaneous
  Kurdish Singer Helly Luv Counters Criticism of Viral Music Video
  Work At Home Mum Makes $10,397/Month Part-Time
  Modern, Folk Kurdish Music Selling Well in Kurdistan
  Lebanese beauty grabs Miss Arab USA title
  Déjà vu? Haifa Wehbe’s bid to be Monica Bellucci
  Who is Clooney’s fiancée Amal Alamuddin?
  Rolling Stones promise 'historic' Cuba concert

Index  |  News  |  Reports  |  Exclusive Interviews  |  Columns‌  |  From Media  |  Miscellaneous  |  Arts  |  Questionnaire  |  Archives  |  Contact us

All rights reserved © gulan-media.com 2005
Developed by: Dashti Ibrahim
Online :19 Visitor : 3256420