English   |   Kurdî   |   كوردى   |   عربى
Art    Sport    Technology    Miscellaneous
Follow us on:
facebook twitter google + skype rss-feed youtube
David Phillips: The trajectory of events in Iraq will result in the country’s fragmentation and the emergence of the world’s newest nation -- “Iraqi Kurdistan.”
Imitating Mohamed Siad Barre makes Iraq like Somalia
Kurds need U.S. help to prevent Islamic State horrors
  •  President Barzani Welcomes UK Government Security Envoy to Kurdistan
  •  Prime Minister Barzani discusses key issues with the press
  •  President Barzani meets commander of US Central Command General Austin
  •  Deputy Prime Minister Talabani: ISIS cannot be allowed a foothold anywhere in Iraq
  •  Belgium to send 13 tonnes of humanitarian aid to Kurdistan
  •  German soldiers arrive in Iraq to deliver aid
  •  Syria conflict: IS 'kills dozens of Assad soldiers'
  •  Ukraine president accuses Russian soldiers of backing rebel thrust
  •  Erdogan sworn in as Turkey's president
  •  France's Hollande rules out cooperation with al-Assad to fight ISIS
Last Updated: 28/08/2014 11:14:18 pm
David Romano - Kurdistan: The good neighbour no one expected
Kurdistan: The good neighbour no one expected
Share
Date: 01/02/2012 : 14:14:09Views: 592
  

In academia, government offices and the media, opponents of Kurdish self-determination always made the same argument: Autonomy in one part of Kurdistan, or a Kurdish state, will breed instability in the Middle East. “If Kurds in Iraq get self-rule,” they said, “they will secede from Iraq and meddle in the politics of neighbouring states.” Kurdish irridentism, according to this line of reasoning, would sacrifice the Middle East’s stability on the altar of the quest for a Greater Kurdistan.

I remember not long ago participating in a debate about the Middle East where one of my academic colleagues, renowned in the field and much more famous than I, kept directing his harshest criticisms, attacks and warnings at the Kurdistan Regional Government of Iraq. Although Moqtada al-Sadr linked death squads were killing Sunnis and Iraqi soldiers in the south, these were just “misunderstood Iraqi nationalists.” The Sunni Arab groups laying improvised explosive devices under Iraqi roads were “insurgents resisting occupation.” The Kurds, however, were the real threat to Iraq and the region, according to him, because of their “maximalist demands” and “destabilizing, risky behaviour.”

If we look at the record of the last several years, however, reality paints a very different picture indeed. It was thanks to the Kurds that every single post-Saddam government in Baghdad got formed and maintained. Kurdish Peshmerga troops accepted American and Government of Iraq requests to send brigades to Anbar and Baghdad and help restore security there, losing scores of their young men’s lives in the process. Kurds serve as President, Foreign Minister and Chief of the Army for Iraq, among other things, and by all accounts have been doing so in a manner that does all Iraqis credit and serves the entire country’s interests. The Kurds compromised on innumerable issues since 2003, including recently the crucial question of how many deputies they get in the parliament in Baghdad. As I write this today, Kurdish leaders are mediating the latest serious conflict to break out between Shiite and Sunni Arab political leaders.

When it comes to the most contentious issues in Iraq, we seem to always see a Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) that prefers to pursue its interests within the institutionalized, legal Iraqi political system. Instead of taking Kirkuk and majority Kurdish territories south of their autonomous region by force, which they could have done on numerous occasions, Kurdish leaders negotiate, bargain and gather promises from other Iraqi parties to address their concerns in a fair and legal manner. When it comes to oil, Iraqi Kurds from the beginning accepted the principle that oil revenues should be distributed throughout Iraq, according to population. While they argue with authorities in Baghdad about the right to sign new oil exploration and exploitation contracts within their region, the 2005 Constitution appears to give them this right – so the argument, again, is a legal dispute regarding Iraqi law rather than some raw power play.

So what about relations with neighbouring states, particularly those with sizeable Kurdish minorities of their own? It’s true that the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) and the Kurdistan Free Life Party (PJAK) have bases in Iraqi Kurdistan, from where they have launched operations against Turkey and Iran, respectively. Their bases remain in extremely rugged mountains of the northeast part of the Kurdistan Autonomous Region, however, out of the control of the Kurdistan Regional Government. This area was never much under Iraqi control even during Saddam’s time, or that of pervious governments. It’s a guerrilla’s dream geography, in short, full of caves, forests, ravines and impenetrable high mountain faces. Although the KRG could have sent and lost many peshmerga up into these mountains to clear them of the PKK and PJAK presence, authorities in Erbil do have many other security worries for which they must conserve resources. Sending the peshmerga to fight other Kurds on behalf of Turkey and Iran would also have proved terribly unpopular amongst the general populace of Iraqi Kurdistan, and just like everywhere else, Iraqi Kurdish leaders must pay at least some heed to popular opinion.

What KRG leaders have done, however, is place limits on the PKK and PJAK’s freedom to operate everywhere in Iraqi Kurdistan. More important, KRG leaders have been actively helping governments in Turkey and Iran negotiate with these groups. Most recently, high level KRG leaders got Iranian forces and PJAK to agree to a cease-fire, putting an end to what was proving a very bloody summer of 2011 on that part of the Iraqi-Iranian border. Other Iranian Kurdish opposition groups – the Kurdistan Democratic Party of Iran (KDPI), Komala and various splinter groups of these parties – all enjoy a presence in Iraqi Kurdistan on the condition that they do not mount armed attacks against Iran. I should think that this policy makes the KRG a better neighbour to Iran than Iran has been to Iraq.

Rather than stir up Kurdish violence in Turkey, KRG leaders act as a channel for the Turkish government to talk to the PKK, in the hopes that the armed conflict between them can be ended. Although Iraqi Kurds can’t solve Turkey’s problems, they have offered their assistance and they certainly haven’t pursued a policy of aggravating tensions in Turkey. At the same time, Turkish business in Iraqi Kurdistan is booming, to the benefit of everyone involved. Who would have thought ten years ago that Turkey would have a consulate in Erbil, or that the Prime Minister and Foreign Minister of Turkey would visit?

When it comes to Syria, Turkey has intervened and spoken out much more against the Assad regime than Iraqi Kurdistan. The most that KRG leaders have done recently was to give permission for Syrian Kurdish opposition groups to hold a conference in Erbil. Although they care deeply about the fate of Syrian Kurds (as they do for those in Turkey and Iran), Iraqi Kurdish leaders seem like the most cautious and soft spoken of Syria’s neighbours. Despite fairly strong popular opinion on the issue, they continue to refrain from involving themselves too deeply in the troubles in Syria.

In short, Iraqi Kurdistan looks more and more like the good neighbour no one expected.

David Romano
The U.S. Government Begins Reappraising Policy on Iraq
Doğu Ergil
KURDISH DILEMMAS OF THE TURKISH STATE
Michael Gunter
THE STUPIDITY OF AMERICAN FOREIGN POLICY
Ted Galen Carpenter
U.S. Should Respect Kurdistan’s Decision about Iraq’s Future
Khaled Salih
Kurdistan is selling oil: From no-one to some-one
Davan Yahya Khalil
Kurdistan – a brief history
Dr. Anwar A. Abdullah (Al-Barzanji)
Kurdistan: Building-up Hard Power
Hemin Hawrami
President Barzani and Kurdistan's Advancement and Success during the Past Eight Years
Dr. Mohammed Sharif
Culture of Hostility to Authority Social Disaster
Professor Jamal Ameen
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly: Mesopotamia from the Cradle of Civilization to a Nest of Terror
Chaim Kaufmann
How the Whole Middle East Disappeared
Alon Ben-Meir
Syria: The Battleground between Sunnis and Shittes
Shilan bibany
Tower and Cancer
News
  Iraqi Kurdistan region to export oil for first time
  Statement by President Barzani on British parliament’s recognition of Kurdish genocide
  Financial Committee, IMF reach agreement on 2012 budget
  Dr. Kamal Kirkuki meets with Henry A. Kissinger
  Korean Culture Festival will be held in Erbil
  Saudi beheading of eight Bangladesh workers condemned
Reports‌
  The Iraqi Government Still Able to Implement Agreements
  Iraq in a stage of post-federalism
  The Effects of Media in the Transitional Stages
  Different Problems of Democracy Development in the Developing Countries
  Violating the Iraqi Constitution Imposes Autocracy and the Return of Dictatorship
  The Golden Jubilee… A Liberation Medallion for the Motto “Either Kurdistan or Dissolution” The September Revolution Still Ongoing
Exclusive Interviews
  Hayat Alvi to Gulan Magazine:In terms of Islamic ideologies in Egypt, the similarities and perspectives are similar to Wahhabis / Salafists in Saudi Arabia
  Ian S. Lustick to Gulan: I imagine the end of the Syrian Regime will be more like that of the Ceaucescu regime in Romania than of other, less violent, transitions in Eastern Europe
  Brendan O'Leary to Gulan Magazine: Only a fool would say the break-up of Iraq will never happen
  Interview of Javier Solana for Gulan magazine - Iraqi Kurdistan
  Interview with the Professor David Romano
Columns‌
  Kurdistan – a brief history
  Turkey & Kurdistan: Prospects for Complementary Economy
  Iraq amid Democracy & Instability
  Recent Western Scholarship on the Kurds in Iraq: A Retrospective
  The Opening of a U.S. Consulate in Hawler
  The Coming US Withdrawal from Iraq
  Kurdistan: Nation & Nature
Miscellaneous
  Work At Home Mum Makes $10,397/Month Part-Time
  Modern, Folk Kurdish Music Selling Well in Kurdistan
  Over 4,000 Kurdish pilgrims expected to undertake Hajj
  Facebook: Friends' Happy Pictures Make You Sad?
  Snow Becomes Beautiful Art In Breckenridge
  Scientists crack Black Death's genetic code
  Football murder probe opened against Qaddafi’s son

Index  |  News  |  Reports  |  Exclusive Interviews  |  Columns‌  |  From Media  |  Miscellaneous  |  Arts  |  Questionnaire  |  Archives  |  Contact us

All rights reserved © gulan-media.com 2005
Developed by: Dashti Ibrahim
Online :26 Visitor : 1106899